An expanded look at the original timeline depicted in episode 10, where Homura and Madoka became friends. When Homura becomes troubled about her lack of talent, Madoka tries using some of her magic to help her out during physical education (PE), but it just causes her to go out of control. After Madoka and Mami save Homura from a witch, Madoka confesses to Homura that she became a magical girl in order to save the life of a cat named Amy who was hit by a car. As a storm hits the city and Homura learns the meaning of Walpurgisnacht, she follows Amy to where Madoka is.